
Silverado Resort
Best for families, golfers, and guests who want many on-site facilities (pools, restaurants, tennis/pickleball) across a large property.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Silverado Resort is a large, family-friendly Napa Valley golf-and-spa resort with multiple pools, restaurants, and two 18-hole championship courses. Dr. Wilkinson's Backyard Resort and Mineral Springs is a smaller, historic Calistoga mineral-springs property for travelers who want soaking tubs, a playful retro vibe, and a central Calistoga location.
Updated · about 28 miles (≈45 km) apart

Best for families, golfers, and guests who want many on-site facilities (pools, restaurants, tennis/pickleball) across a large property.

Best for visitors who want authentic Calistoga mineral baths, a compact property with personality, and quick access to downtown Calistoga.
When Silverado Resort wins: Choose Silverado when you want a full-service Napa Valley base with golf, many dining outlets, multiple pools, a large spa program, and family-friendly programming on an extensive property.
When Dr. Wilkinson's Backyard Resort and Mineral Springs wins: Pick Dr. Wilkinson’s when your priority is historic Calistoga hot springs, a smaller property within walking distance of Calistoga’s shops and wineries, and a more intimate, retro-focused stay.
Bottom line: Silverado is a wide-ranging, activity-forward resort for families and groups; Dr. Wilkinson’s is a distinct Calistoga mineral-springs alternative that delivers local soaking experiences and a compact, characterful stay.
| Category | Silverado Resort | Dr. Wilkinson's Backyard Resort and Mineral Springs |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, resort-style, activity-focused (golf, family pools, many venues) | Historic mineral-springs, boutique, nostalgic and playful |
| Location | On Atlas Peak Road near Silverado Trail, a few minutes outside downtown Napa | In downtown Calistoga, within blocks of Calistoga Hot Springs and local shops |
| Size | About 350 rooms across ~1,200 acres | 50 guestrooms (small property) |
| Ages | All ages welcome; family-friendly with kids’ facilities | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools & soaking | Multiple outdoor pools (main Resort Pool open daily), family-focused pool areas | Two outdoor pools and 1 indoor pool; hot springs nearby and on-site hot tub(s) |
| Restaurants & bars | Several venues including Matchplay Kitchen + Bar, Mansion Bar & Terrace, Market & Bakery, Forno Pizza, Boost Café, Burgerdog | One restaurant and one bar/lounge on property; cooked-to-order breakfast available (fee) |
| Spa & wellness | 16,000 sq ft Spa at Silverado with extensive treatment menu and fitness center | Full-service spa and mineral-springs bathing; steam room and spa services offered |
| Known for | Golf, family pools, event and wedding venues across many acres | Calistoga mineral baths and a historic, retro-inspired guest experience |
| Meeting & event space | Many indoor/outdoor venues and ballrooms for large weddings and conferences | 4 meeting rooms for small to mid-sized events |
| On-site activities | Tennis, pickleball, golf, fitness classes, shuttle around property | Bicycle rentals, outdoor entertainment area, picnic area, firepit |
Silverado sits off Atlas Peak Road near the Silverado Trail with easy access to hundreds of Napa wineries.
Silverado is a large, spread-out Napa resort best for guests who plan to use on-site amenities and explore the valley by car.
Dr. Wilkinson's is located in downtown Calistoga, a short walk from Calistoga Hot Springs and local wineries.
Dr. Wilkinson’s is convenient for visitors who want to stay in Calistoga and spend time in town or at nearby hot springs.
Silverado offers many room and suite types across cottages, mansion rooms, and larger multi-bedroom suites.
Choose Silverado for a wide selection of room types and larger suites for families or group stays.
Dr. Wilkinson’s has 50 guestrooms with a compact choice of room formats and courtyard options.
Dr. Wilkinson’s is a smaller, simpler property with straightforward room types and retro character.
Silverado runs several on-site food and beverage outlets covering casual and full-service dining.
Silverado gives you many on-site dining styles — from quick grab-and-go to a full-service seasonal restaurant.
Dr. Wilkinson’s has one restaurant and a bar/lounge on property and serves cooked-to-order breakfasts for a fee.
Expect fewer on-site dining options at Dr. Wilkinson’s but easy access to Calistoga’s restaurants and wine bars.
Silverado emphasizes multiple outdoor pools and family-friendly pool facilities across its grounds.
Silverado’s pools are designed for families and guests who want varied pool options on-site.
Dr. Wilkinson’s is known for its Calistoga hot-springs connection and on-site pools and hot tubs.
If soaking in thermal waters is a priority, Dr. Wilkinson’s delivers a focused mineral-springs experience close to Calistoga’s hot springs.
Silverado’s large spa and fitness center is a major draw, supported by fitness classes and wellness facilities.
Silverado suits guests who want a broad wellness program and evening dining/entertainment without leaving the property.
Dr. Wilkinson’s offers full-service spa treatments tied to its mineral-springs identity and small-scale evening options.
Pick Dr. Wilkinson’s for focused mineral-springs wellness and quiet evenings with nearby downtown Calistoga nightlife if you want more variety.

Silverado — multiple pools, kids’ activities, family dining options, and large suites for groups.

Dr. Wilkinson’s — direct Calistoga mineral-springs identity, hot tub and steam room access, and proximity to town soaks.

Silverado — several restaurants and cafes covering everything from quick bites to full-service seasonal dining.

Dr. Wilkinson’s — central address in Calistoga with easy walking access to local shops, tasting rooms, and attractions.
Silverado — it has extensive on-site activities (golf, many pools, tennis/pickleball, large spa, multiple restaurants) that let you stay on property for most needs.
Dr. Wilkinson’s — it’s in downtown Calistoga and is known for its mineral-springs connection and on-site soaking-related amenities.
No — both properties welcome guests of all ages; Dr. Wilkinson’s is explicitly not adults-only per its listing.
At Silverado a car or the resort shuttle is useful because the property is large and spread out; at Dr. Wilkinson’s you can walk to many Calistoga sights but will need a car for broader Napa Valley exploration.
Explore how Silverado Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·