
Silverado Resort
Best for families, golfers, and large events — choose Silverado when you want extensive on-site activities, multiple pools, and large meeting/wedding capacities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Silverado Resort is a large, family-friendly Napa Valley resort built around two 18-hole PGA courses with multiple pools, courts, and big event spaces; this guide is for travelers who want active outdoor amenities, golf, or family-focused resort programming. MacArthur Place Hotel & Spa is a five-star Sonoma boutique hotel with garden grounds, a single pool and a full-service spa; this guide is for couples or small groups who prioritize intimate boutique character and a central Sonoma location.
Updated · about 31 km (19 miles) apart

Best for families, golfers, and large events — choose Silverado when you want extensive on-site activities, multiple pools, and large meeting/wedding capacities.

Best for boutique Sonoma stays and quiet, garden-facing relaxation — choose MacArthur Place when you want a compact, luxury hotel near Sonoma Plaza and a full-service spa.
When Silverado Resort wins: Pick Silverado if you want on-property golf, tennis/pickleball, multiple pools and family-oriented programming, or if you need large indoor/outdoor event and wedding capacity.
When MacArthur Place wins: Pick MacArthur Place Hotel & Spa if you prefer a smaller, individually decorated boutique hotel in downtown Sonoma with garden views, a single outdoor pool, and a full-service spa for a quieter, walkable stay.
Bottom line: Silverado is a sprawling activity-focused resort for families, golfers, and groups; MacArthur Place is a smaller, luxury Sonoma pied-à-terre for guests who value boutique character, proximity to Sonoma Plaza, and spa time.
| Category | Silverado Resort | MacArthur Place Hotel & Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, activity-focused resort with golf courses, courts, and family programming | Luxury boutique hotel with garden-like, intimate grounds |
| Location | Outside downtown Napa on roughly 1,200 acres along Atlas Peak / near the Silverado Trail | Historic district of Sonoma, about a block from Sonoma Plaza |
| Size | About 350 rooms across a sprawling property and multiple buildings | 64 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages — family-friendly with kids’ facilities and family pools | All ages — not adults-only; suitable for couples and small groups |
| Pools | Multiple outdoor pools (including a family-friendly main pool) and a spa pool | One outdoor pool and one hot tub/steam room at the full-service spa |
| Restaurants & bars | Several on-site options: Matchplay Kitchen + Bar, Mansion Bar & Terrace, Market & Bakery, Forno Pizza, Boost Café, Burgerdog (casual to full-service) | One main restaurant, Layla (Californian cuisine) plus pool bar and limited room service |
| Spa & wellness | The Spa at Silverado: a 16,000-sq-ft spa and fitness center with many treatment rooms, sauna, steam room, whirlpool, classes | Full-service spa with massage, body treatments, facials, steam room and a single hot tub; spa treatment rooms on site |
| Known for | Two 18-hole PGA championship golf courses, event capacity and family amenities | Boutique Sonoma charm, garden setting, and proximity to Sonoma Plaza |
| Meeting & event space | Extensive indoor/outdoor event venues and high overall capacity for weddings and conferences | Conference center with about 6,500 sq ft and 7 meeting rooms for smaller events |
| Parking & transport | Complimentary self-parking and resort-wide shuttle; some airport shuttle options (fee applies) | Secured parking and valet (surcharge); centrally walkable to local shops and Sonoma Plaza |
Silverado sits on roughly 1,200 acres a few minutes off the Silverado Trail outside downtown Napa.
Silverado is remote within Napa Valley and geared to guests who plan to drive or use resort transport to access on-site activities.
MacArthur Place is in Sonoma’s historic district — a short walk to Sonoma Plaza and local shops.
Choose MacArthur Place for a walkable Sonoma base near the plaza and town amenities.
Silverado offers a wide roster of room and suite types across cottages, mansion rooms, and multi-bedroom suites.
Silverado gives many room-size choices for families and groups, from simple rooms to large multi-bedroom suites.
MacArthur Place has 64 individually decorated guestrooms and a small set of cottages and suites.
MacArthur Place suits travelers who want individually styled rooms and a compact hotel layout in Sonoma.
Silverado has multiple on-site dining outlets spanning full-service to casual grab-and-go.
Silverado’s multiple venues make it easy to find something for kids, golfers, or a formal dinner without leaving property.
MacArthur Place centers food and drink around one main restaurant and more limited on-site outlets.
MacArthur Place is best if you prefer a single high-quality restaurant and don’t mind walking into Sonoma for more variety.
Pools are a core family amenity at Silverado, with several outdoor pools on the grounds.
If multiple pool options and family-friendly pool hours matter, Silverado is the stronger choice.
MacArthur Place offers a single outdoor pool plus a hot tub and steam room connected to the spa.
MacArthur Place is better for guests who want a quiet pool in a garden setting rather than multiple family pools.
Silverado’s wellness offering centers on a large spa and a sizable fitness program, with on-site nightlife limited to bars and live music.
Silverado works for guests seeking extensive wellness facilities plus casual evening entertainment on property.
MacArthur Place focuses on boutique spa services and a calmer evening scene tied to downtown Sonoma.
MacArthur Place suits travelers who plan spa time and want to step into Sonoma nightlife rather than rely on hotel entertainment.

Silverado — two 18-hole PGA championship golf courses and on-site golf services.

MacArthur Place — small luxury property within easy walking distance of Sonoma Plaza.

Silverado — multiple pools, kids’ activities and family-friendly dining options.

MacArthur Place — full-service spa in a quiet garden setting and heated-floor guestrooms.
Silverado — it’s explicitly family-friendly with multiple pools, kids’ programming, casual dining and spacious grounds.
MacArthur Place — it sits in Sonoma’s historic district, a short walk from Sonoma Plaza and local dining.
Both have full-service spas, but MacArthur Place is a smaller boutique spa experience in Sonoma while Silverado’s Spa at Silverado is a much larger facility with broader wellness amenities.
Silverado is set up for large weddings and conferences with extensive indoor/outdoor venues and high capacity; MacArthur Place offers around 6,500 sq ft of event space suited to smaller meetings and events.
Explore how Silverado Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·